GridWits
Extreme tier Technique 9 of 9 Used by Smart Hint

Trial and Refutation

Try a cell both ways: reject a branch that fails, or keep any other mark both surviving branches agree on.

How it works

  1. 1Only two cells in the whole grid can light the top-right corner: the corner itself and the marked cell under it, because the 1's wall cuts the corner's row and another wall cuts its column two down.
  2. 2Nothing here follows by ordinary reasoning, so suppose a bulb goes in the cell directly below the 1, and follow it.
  3. 3It lights its own whole row, which empties the cell under the corner; and it fills the 1, which empties the 1's other neighbours — the corner among them.
  4. 4Both of the corner's sources are gone, so the supposition strands it in the dark forever: the cell below the 1 is empty. The same rung also tries EMPTY when that is the forcing branch, and keeps consequences shared by both branches. Needing any trial form is what makes a board Extreme.
1
  • Cells that establish the pattern
  • Cell this technique rules out